Old Enough To Be Used, Expensive Enough To Surprise You
Buying a used truck used to mean letting somebody else take the big depreciation hit. That still works sometimes, but plenty of pickups refuse to get cheap nearly as quickly as buyers expect. These are the used trucks that make shoppers wonder if somebody forgot to tell the seller they aren’t new anymore.
Toyota Tacoma (2016–2023)
Few used trucks punish bargain hunters quite like the third-generation Tacoma. Its reputation for durability, strong off-road trims, huge aftermarket, and constant demand mean even older TRD Off-Road and TRD Pro examples can carry eye-opening prices. Current resale studies still put the Tacoma at the top of the midsize-truck category. You can save versus buying new, but finding a genuinely cheap clean Tacoma is another matter entirely.
Nissan Frontier (2013–2021)
The previous-generation Frontier is appealing because it stayed fundamentally similar for years, giving buyers a simple V6 truck without much unnecessary complexity. It generally costs less than an equivalent Tacoma, but good crew-cab 4x4 examples haven’t exactly collapsed in value either. The design became ancient by modern standards, yet that simplicity eventually became part of the attraction. Buyers looking for an honest midsize pickup still keep demand surprisingly healthy.
MercurySable99, Wikimedia Commons
Ford Ranger (2019–2023)
When Ford brought the Ranger back to the American market, it landed right in the middle of a rapidly growing midsize-truck segment. Its turbocharged four-cylinder produced strong torque, while the manageable size made it easier to live with than an F-150. Used Rangers are now old enough to offer meaningful savings, but resale remains strong compared with many vehicles. Clean FX4 trucks in particular can still cost much more than their age might suggest.
SsmIntrigue, Wikimedia Commons
Chevrolet Colorado (2015–2022)
The second-generation Colorado gave buyers more variety than many midsize rivals, including four-cylinder, V6, and diesel power during its run. That broad lineup means there are affordable trucks out there, but desirable crew-cab 4x4s and ZR2 models can remain surprisingly expensive. The Colorado’s useful size and legitimate towing capability keep it relevant even beside newer trucks. It’s old enough to be a value play without feeling especially old.
GMC Canyon (2015–2022)
The Canyon shared most of its mechanical pieces with the Colorado but dressed them in slightly more upscale clothing. That matters on the used market, where well-equipped SLT and Denali examples can still carry a noticeable premium. Buyers get midsize dimensions without giving up leather, nicer trim, or strong towing capability. Current resale rankings also place the Canyon among the better value-holders in the midsize segment, which helps explain why nice ones don’t always look cheap.
SsmIntrigue, Wikimedia Commons
Honda Ridgeline (2017–2023)
The Ridgeline has always been the truck for people who don’t necessarily need a traditional truck. Its unibody construction gives it a smoother ride, while the dual-action tailgate, lockable in-bed trunk, and roomy cab make it unusually practical. Second-generation models can now be found well below their original prices, but well-kept examples still hold respectable value. There’s simply not much else that combines pickup usefulness with this much everyday comfort.
Ford Maverick (2022–2024)
The Maverick was supposed to be the affordable little truck, which makes its used-market strength especially funny. Huge early demand, limited supply, a useful compact footprint, and the availability of an efficient hybrid kept pre-owned examples surprisingly close to their original pricing for quite a while. Depreciation has become more normal, but the Maverick still ranks among the strongest small pickups for resale. Apparently inexpensive trucks become less inexpensive when everybody wants one.
Toyota Tundra (2014–2021)
Pre-2022 Tundras have developed an almost cult-like appeal, particularly among buyers who prefer the naturally aspirated V8 over the newer turbocharged powertrains. The 5.7-liter V8 isn’t remotely economical, but durability and simplicity matter more to plenty of used-truck shoppers. That demand keeps clean 4x4 examples stubbornly expensive. Current resale studies put the Tundra among the very strongest full-size trucks for value retention, even before considering the reputation of this specific generation.
Rutger van der Maar, Wikimedia Commons
Ford F-150 (2015–2020)
There are millions of F-150s around, which should theoretically make them dirt cheap. The problem is that desirable configurations remain desirable. Crew cabs, four-wheel drive, popular EcoBoost engines, V8s, and higher trims can still command substantial prices even after years of use. This aluminum-bodied generation is modern enough to feel current while being old enough to avoid new-truck pricing, putting it right in the used-market sweet spot.
Mr.choppers, Wikimedia Commons
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (2014–2018)
The 2014–2018 Silverado is common enough that shoppers have plenty to choose from, but clean examples aren’t always the bargain that abundance suggests. Crew-cab 4x4s with the 5.3-liter V8 remain especially easy to sell because they hit a useful middle ground between capability and complexity. Parts availability is excellent, practically every shop knows how to work on them, and buyers still recognize the formula. A decade old doesn’t automatically mean cheap anymore.
GMC Sierra 1500 (2014–2018)
Take the Silverado formula, add more polished styling and expensive trim levels, and you get a truck that can retain a surprisingly high used-market ceiling. SLT and Denali models are the clearest examples because buyers continue to pay extra for leather, premium interiors, and familiar V8 power. Plenty of these trucks have serious mileage now, yet clean ones can still carry ambitious asking prices. Luxury pickups age differently when the basic truck underneath remains useful.
Ram 1500 (2019–2023)
The fifth-generation Ram immediately stood out because its interior felt considerably more upscale than most rival pickups. That advantage hasn’t disappeared on the used market. Early trucks have depreciated enough to be more accessible, but desirable Laramie, Limited, Rebel, and Hemi-equipped models can still cost real money. The coil-spring rear suspension also gives the Ram a comfortable ride that helps it appeal beyond traditional work-truck buyers.
Ethan Llamas, Wikimedia Commons
Nissan Titan (2017–2023)
The second-generation Titan never challenged the Detroit trucks in sales, and that actually makes it interesting used. Prices can be lower than comparable F-150s or Tundras, yet clean examples haven’t become worthless because buyers still get a full-size truck with standard V8 power. Nissan’s long factory warranty helped its original value proposition too. It isn’t the strongest resale champion here, but good Titans can hold enough value to surprise shoppers expecting a forgotten bargain.
DestinationFearFan, Wikimedia Commons
Ram 1500 Classic (2019–2024)
Ram kept the previous-generation 1500 alive alongside its replacement for years, creating one of the strangest truck bargains of the period. The Classic offered familiar Hemi power, proven hardware, and a lower entry price than the newer Ram. Because production continued so long, buyers can find relatively young examples that still feel decidedly old-school. Prices vary widely, but well-equipped 4x4s show how much demand remains for a simple, familiar full-size pickup.
MercurySable99, Wikimedia Commons
Jeep Gladiator (2020–2023)
The Gladiator combines two things that traditionally resist depreciation: Jeeps and pickup trucks. Early examples have dropped significantly from some of their inflated pandemic-era prices, but they still benefit from Wrangler styling, removable doors and roof panels, four-wheel drive, and strong enthusiast interest. Rubicon and Mojave versions are particularly desirable. It may be quirky, but there isn’t another midsize truck that offers quite the same open-air experience.
Hyundai Santa Cruz (2022–2024)
Hyundai insists on calling the Santa Cruz a sport adventure vehicle, but used buyers know there’s a pickup bed hanging off the back. Its car-like ride, compact dimensions, clever bed storage, and available turbocharged engine give it a different audience from traditional trucks. Because the compact-pickup category remains tiny, clean used Santa Cruzes don’t face much direct competition. Current resale data also shows surprisingly strong value retention for the little Hyundai.
Ford F-250 Super Duty (2017–2022)
This is where used-truck pricing starts getting truly shocking. A six- or eight-year-old F-250 with four-wheel drive, a crew cab, and the Power Stroke diesel can still carry a price that would buy a very nice new car. Buyers who tow heavy trailers aren’t shopping for style alone; they need capability. That keeps demand high, and current resale studies place the F-250 among the strongest heavy-duty trucks for retained value.
Ram 2500 (2014–2018)
Older Cummins-powered Ram 2500s prove that high mileage doesn’t automatically destroy a truck’s value. The 6.7-liter diesel has a loyal following, and buyers searching for towing capability often prefer paying for a proven older truck over stepping into the enormous price of a new one. Clean crew-cab 4x4 versions can therefore command startling money. Current data still shows the Ram 2500 retaining a very large portion of its value after five years.
Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD (2015–2019)
The Silverado 2500HD occupies a sweet spot where trucks are old enough to avoid today’s new-HD prices but modern enough to handle serious towing without feeling ancient. Gas-powered work trucks can be relatively approachable, while Duramax diesel crew cabs are a completely different story. Desirable diesel 4x4s often retain impressive value because commercial, recreational, and towing buyers are all fighting over the same trucks.
GMC Sierra 2500HD (2015–2019)
The Sierra 2500HD adds GMC’s upscale image to the same heavy-duty fundamentals found in the Silverado. That becomes particularly noticeable with Denali diesels, which can still command staggering prices despite age and mileage. Buyers get genuine towing capability without giving up luxury features, so demand comes from both truck users and people who simply like expensive pickups. Current resale rankings put the Sierra 2500HD among the strongest heavy-duty value holders.
Charles from Port Chester, New York, Wikimedia Commons
Nissan Titan XD (2020–2023)
The Titan XD sits in an unusual space between conventional half-ton pickups and true heavy-duty trucks. Later versions dropped the earlier Cummins diesel and relied on Nissan’s 5.6-liter gasoline V8, simplifying the lineup considerably. Used examples can represent good value compared with the Detroit heavy-duty trucks, yet they still retain meaningful prices because production numbers were relatively limited. Its odd positioning hurt sales new, but makes it an interesting used alternative now.
Ford F-350 Super Duty (2017–2022)
The F-350 makes even used F-250 prices look understandable. Diesel crew-cab 4x4s, particularly well-equipped ones, can remain enormously valuable because buyers shopping this class usually have an actual job for the truck. Payload and towing capability are expensive to replace, and buying new can push prices into luxury-car territory. Current resale data ranks the F-350 near the very top of the entire heavy-duty segment.
Ram 3500 (2014–2018)
If you want proof that an older work truck can behave like an appreciating asset, look at clean Cummins-powered Ram 3500s. Dual-rear-wheel models, four-wheel drive, and desirable crew-cab configurations can still bring serious money long after an ordinary vehicle from the same year has become cheap transportation. The numbers back up the reputation, too. Current resale studies rank the Ram 3500 as the strongest heavy-duty pickup for five-year value retention.
MercurySable99, Wikimedia Commons
Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD (2015–2019)
The Silverado 3500HD was never meant to be inexpensive transportation, and age hasn’t changed that as much as buyers might hope. Basic work trucks can become affordable, but Duramax diesel crew cabs and dual-rear-wheel versions remain valuable because their capability is difficult to replace cheaply. Contractors, RV owners, and heavy-towing buyers keep the demand alive. Even a decade-old truck can therefore carry an asking price that initially looks like a typo.
GMC Sierra 3500HD (2015–2019)
The Sierra 3500HD takes the heavy-duty resale problem and adds luxury-truck pricing on top. A Denali with the Duramax diesel can be years old, heavily used, and still cost more than many brand-new crossovers. That sounds ridiculous until you consider what buyers are getting: massive towing ability, a premium cabin, and expensive diesel hardware. Current resale data places the Sierra 3500HD among GMC’s very strongest vehicles for holding value.
You May Also Like:
Foreign Pickup Trucks Americans Still Wish They Could Buy
Square-Body Trucks That Quietly Became Collector Favorites—Do You Think They Should Make A Comeback?
