The 20 Best And 20 Worst Cities For Drivers In America

The 20 Best And 20 Worst Cities For Drivers In America


October 24, 2024 | Jesse Singer

The 20 Best And 20 Worst Cities For Drivers In America


Wanna Go For A Drive?

Most of us spend way too much time in our cars—with the average person in America spending about 370 hours on the road each year. But all time isn't equal and 370 hours in one city can be much better—or much worse—than 370 hours in another.

Best Worst Driving Cities L

Advertisement

Methodology

Before we jump into it, a quick note on the data: These rankings were calculated in 2024 by WalletHub, based on over 30 different criteria across four main headings: Cost of Ownership & Maintenance, Traffic & Infrastructure, Safety, and Access to Vehicles & Maintenance.

Across these four headings, they looked at everything from fuel and insurance prices to time spent in traffic and road quality. They also took into consideration the likelihood of accidents, car theft rates, and hard-braking events per 1,000 miles. The number of gas stations, auto repair shops, and parking lots per capita were also factored into the final weighted average score for each city. 100 cities were ranked and these are the top 20 and the bottom 20 in said ranking (with numbers 1-20 being the best and 80-100 being the worst).

#20: Toledo, OH (58.02)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 5

Traffic & Infrastructure: 40

Safety: 66

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 71

Empty Jefferson Street in Toledo, OhioCounselman Collection, Flickr

Advertisement

#80: Aurora, CO (46.1)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 55

Traffic & Infrastructure: 90

Safety: 83

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 77

Colfax Avenue located in Aurora, ColoradoKen Lund, Flickr

Advertisement

#19: Arlington, TX (58.46)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 30

Traffic & Infrastructure: 60

Safety: 26

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 22

Aerial view of the city of Arlington, TexasTallmaple, Shutterstock

Advertisement

#81: Stockton, CA (45.95)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 85

Traffic & Infrastructure: 54

Safety: 43

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 82

Aerial view of Stockton, CaliforniaDJ Fogbound, Flickr

Advertisement

#18: Tulsa, OK (58.82)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 41

Traffic & Infrastructure: 5

Safety: 51

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 40

Route 66 Bridge located in Tulsa, OklahomaNicolas Henderson, Flickr

Advertisement

#82: Baltimore, MD (45.61)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 63

Traffic & Infrastructure: 83

Safety: 80

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 73

View south along Maryland State Route 41Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#17: Lubbock, TX (58.94)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 35

Traffic & Infrastructure: 3

Safety: 60

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 67

Lubbock Skyline at sundown in TexasNoah Puente, CC0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#83: Newark, NJ (45.24)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 73

Traffic & Infrastructure: 95

Safety: 55

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 21

Crowded Downtown in Newark, New JerseyKen Lund, Flickr

Advertisement

#16: Lexington-Fayette, KY (58.96)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 6

Traffic & Infrastructure: 43

Safety: 31

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 95

Aerial view of the city of Lexington, KYGrindstone Media Group, Shutterstock

Advertisement

#84: San Bernardino, CA (45.16)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 93

Traffic & Infrastructure: 22

Safety: 74

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 42

Afternoon view of San Bernardino Mountain in CaliforniaMatt Gush, Shutterstock

Advertisement

#15: Durham, NC (59.10)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 7

Traffic & Infrastructure: 44

Safety: 32

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 85

An intersection located in Durham, NCIldar Sagdejev, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#85: New Orleans, LA (45.16)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 65

Traffic & Infrastructure: 76

Safety: 84

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 96

Crowded Bourbon Street in New Orleans, Louisiana, USADomenico Convertini, Flickr

Advertisement

#14: Fort Wayne, IN (59.14)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 23

Traffic & Infrastructure: 39

Safety: 21

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 64

A view of downtown Fort Wayne, IndianaNortheast Indiana Regional Partnership, Flickr

Advertisement

#86: Boston, MA (45.15)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 68

Traffic & Infrastructure: 94

Safety: 35

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 87

Aerial view of Boston cityscape, MassachusettsBert Kaufmann, Flickr

Advertisement

#13: Lincoln, NE (59.32)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 18

Traffic & Infrastructure: 52

Safety: 12

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 89

Aerial View of Downtown Lincoln, Nebraskaedward stojakovic, Flickr

Advertisement

#87: San Diego, CA (45.04)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 95

Traffic & Infrastructure: 51

Safety: 30

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 29

Gas Lamp Quarter in San Diego, California, USADietmar Rabich, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#12: Winston-Salem, NC (60.05)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 3

Traffic & Infrastructure: 26

Safety: 40

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 94

Aerial view of Winston-Salem, North CarolinaPaul Sableman, Flickr

Advertisement

#88: Milwaukee, WI (44.22)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 70

Traffic & Infrastructure: 85

Safety: 82

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 61

An empty road in Milwaukee, WisconsinDori, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#11: Birmingham, AL (60.17)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 8

Traffic & Infrastructure: 10

Safety: 87

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 8

Busy Downtown in Birmingham, AlabamaBjoertvedt, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#89: Portland, OR (44.00)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 75

Traffic & Infrastructure: 86

Safety: 78

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 38

Aerial shot of the Morrison Bridge in Portland, OregonJoanieB, Shutterstock

Advertisement

#10: Plano, TX (60.52)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 40

Traffic & Infrastructure: 37

Safety: 13

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 28

Legacy Town Center located in Plano, TXEric Fredericks, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#90: Denver, CO (43.48)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 69

Traffic & Infrastructure: 87

Safety: 86

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 45

Denver City Center from Coors Field located in DenverKen Lund, Flickr

Advertisement

#9: Tampa, FL (60.66)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 36

Traffic & Infrastructure: 24

Safety: 41

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 4

Downtown skyline of Tampa, Florida, USASean Pavone, Shutterstock

Advertisement

#91: San Jose, CA (43.22)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 97

Traffic & Infrastructure: 65

Safety: 34

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 78

Empty SoFA District located in San Jose, CAEric Fredericks, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#8: Wichita, KS (61.39)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 21

Traffic & Infrastructure: 6

Safety: 24

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 88

A skyline located in Wichita, KansasWeaponizingArchitecture, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#92: Seattle, WA (42.59)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 84

Traffic & Infrastructure: 81

Safety: 67

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 84

The city of Seattle, Washington in the fallWonderlane, Flickr

Advertisement

#7: Scottsdale, AZ (62.04)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 61

Traffic & Infrastructure: 1

Safety: 8

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 25

A view of Old Town located in Scottsdale, ArizonaDru Bloomfield, Flickr

Advertisement

#93: Washington, DC (39.41)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 62

Traffic & Infrastructure: 97

Safety: 94

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 75

Congestion along M Street in Washington DCEricjonesdotcom, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#6: Orlando, FL (62.06)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 37

Traffic & Infrastructure: 2

Safety: 69

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 2

View of a highway of downtown Orlando, FloridaSean Pavone, Shutterstock

Advertisement

#94: New York, NY (38.02)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 90

Traffic & Infrastructure: 100

Safety: 20

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 80

A street in Upper Manhattan - New York CityMaciek Lulko, Flickr

Advertisement

#5: Jacksonville, FL (62.46)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 4

Traffic & Infrastructure: 21

Safety: 39

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 34

A busy road in Jacksonville, FloridaKevin Burke, Flickr

Advertisement

#95: Chicago, IL (37.20)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 89

Traffic & Infrastructure: 99

Safety: 56

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 46

Busy Jackson Boulevard located in Chicago, IllinoisKen Lund, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#4: Greensboro, NC (62.63)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 1

Traffic & Infrastructure: 18

Safety: 64

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 35

A calm street in Greensboro, North CarolinaWarren LeMay, CC0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#96: Detroit, MI (36.85)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 77

Traffic & Infrastructure: 89

Safety: 99

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 50

Historic district Corktown located in Detroit, MichiganKen Lund, Flickr

Advertisement

#3: Corpus Christi, TX (62.94)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 10

Traffic & Infrastructure: 8

Safety: 16

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 86

The downtown of the city of Corpus Christi in TexasMglsndst1993, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#97: Los Angeles, CA (36.57)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 99

Traffic & Infrastructure: 91

Safety: 61

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 44

Downtown LA with smog, Los Angeles, CAtraveljunction, Flickr

Advertisement

#2: Boise, ID (63.41)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 26

Traffic & Infrastructure: 23

Safety: 1

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 81

View of Idaho State Capitol in Downtown Boise, IdahoRoman Eugeniusz, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#98: San Francisco, CA (36.20)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 94

Traffic & Infrastructure: 93

Safety: 77

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 60

Busy California Street located in San Francisco, United StatesRezaul Karim, CC0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#1: Raleigh, NC (63.92)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 2

Traffic & Infrastructure: 33

Safety: 22

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 30

Fayetteville Street In Downtown Raleigh, North CarolinaBz3rk, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#99: Philadelphia, PA (35.70)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 81

Traffic & Infrastructure: 96

Safety: 93

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 76

View of City Hall in Philadelphia, PennsylvaniaJohn Phelan, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

#100: Oakland, CA (32.75)

Cost of Ownership & Maintenance: 100

Traffic & Infrastructure: 79

Safety: 95

Access to Vehicles & Maintenance: 51

Aerial view of the MacArthur Maze in Oakland, CAWirestock Creators, Shutterstock

Advertisement

READ MORE

Steering Wheel

60s Cars That Everyone Loved

Cars in the 60s were an extension of one’s personality. Driven to capture the spirit of an unforgettable era, this article unveils the standout features that defined 1960s cars.
January 27, 2025 Miles Brucker
Dodge Weapon Carrier

The Dodge Brothers Left Ford And Built An Empire That Changed History

What if you were pivotal for an automotive giant but decided to walk away? This is the story of the Dodge brothers, whose departure from Ford Motor Company was the birth of a new legacy.
January 17, 2025 Miles Brucker
Nelson Piquet, Nigel Mansell, Williams-Honda FW11B, Grand Prix of Austria, Osterreichring, 16 August 1987. Nelson Piquet leads Williams-Honda teammate Nigel Mansell in a shower of sparks

The Weirdest F1 Race Finishes

When Nigel Mansell’s gearbox failed just before the end of a race, the desperate driver tried to push his car across the finish line—but the consequences were devastating.
February 9, 2025 Samantha Henman
Cadillac_Deville_convertible

The Timeless Evolution Of Cadillac

Trivia time: what do Adam Sandler, Marilyn Monroe, Clark Gable, Clint Eastwood, and Rita Hayworth have in common? They all loved their Cadillacs. What made them fall in love with the brand that rewrote the standards of the industry?
January 5, 2025 Peter Kinney
Lincoln Motor Company

The Lincoln Motor Company secured a $10 million government contract in 1917 and started a journey that transformed automobile manufacturing forever.

Edsel Ford once said, "Father made the most popular cars; I want to make the best," and that's precisely what The Lincoln Motor Company did. So, here's how the company began and continues to craft its cars.
January 16, 2025 Peter Kinney
Chevrolet_Impala_LTZ

Everyone Love It For A Reason: The Reign Of The Chevrolet Impala

Imagine a car that wasn't just about transportation but was a rolling piece of engineering brilliance. The Chevy Impala drove the highways of possibility, turning every mile into a story of power and spirit.
January 28, 2025 Peter Kinney