Frustrated driver reacting to expensive fuel bills while holding a dispenser handle at a petrol station

Things Drivers Think Will Improve Their Gas Mileage, But Can Actually Make It Worse


October 22, 2026 | J. Clarke

Things Drivers Think Will Improve Their Gas Mileage, But Can Actually Make It Worse


When Saving Gas Ends Up Costing You More

Everyone wants to squeeze a few extra miles out of a tank of gas, especially when prices keep climbing. Unfortunately, some supposedly clever fuel-saving tricks can actually make your car less efficient. From questionable driving habits to expensive products promising miraculous results, plenty of popular advice doesn't hold up under scrutiny. Here are 29 things that might be doing your gas mileage more harm than good.

Frustrated driver reacting to expensive fuel bills while holding a dispenser handle at a petrol stationRabizo Anatolii, Shutterstock Images

Advertisement

Filling Up With Premium Gasoline

Premium sounds better, but higher octane doesn't automatically mean better mileage. If your engine is designed for regular gasoline, premium generally provides no efficiency improvement. You're simply paying extra for the same journey.

91 octane premium unleaded gasoline, no ethanol added (ethanol free fuel) gas pump, at a Kwik Trip fueling station in Hinckley, Minnesota.Tony Webster from Minneapolis, Minnesota, United States, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Choosing E85 Because It Has Higher Octane

E85 offers high octane, but ethanol contains less energy per gallon than gasoline. Even in compatible flex-fuel vehicles, switching to E85 generally reduces miles per gallon. A lower pump price doesn't guarantee lower driving costs.

An E85 (85% ethanol) gas pump at a fueling station in Inver Grove Heights, Minnesota.
- 

(C) 2018 Tony WebsterTony Webster from Minneapolis, Minnesota, United States, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Buying The Cheapest Gas Without Considering Quality

The cheapest gasoline isn't necessarily the smartest long-term purchase. Fuel with fewer effective detergent additives can allow engine deposits to accumulate, potentially reducing efficiency. Gasoline meeting TOP TIER standards helps control those deposits.

Close-up of a hand holding a nozzle while refueling a car at a gas station.Erik Mclean, Pexels

Advertisement

Pouring In Miracle Fuel Additives

Those little bottles promising dramatic mileage improvements sound tempting. Unfortunately, testing has found that many aftermarket additives provide no meaningful fuel savings. Some questionable products can even damage engines or increase emissions.

a display in a store filled with lots of bottlesMorgan Vander Hart, Unsplash

Advertisement

Installing Electronic Fuel-Saving Gadgets

Plug-in devices promising instant efficiency improvements deserve skepticism. Federal testing has found no significant mileage improvement from many aftermarket fuel-saving products. Spending money on an unproven gadget won't necessarily make your engine use less gasoline.

GM OBD OBD2 adapter cableHans Haase, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Lowering Tire Pressure For Better Grip

Softer tires might feel more comfortable, but underinflation increases rolling resistance. Your engine must work harder to keep the car moving. Proper inflation helps protect your fuel economy, tires, and handling.

Mechanic inspecting and adjusting tire pressure in an auto repair shop.Andrea Piacquadio, Pexels

Advertisement

Installing Bigger Wheels To Cover More Ground

Bigger wheels might seem efficient because they require fewer rotations per mile. However, larger wheel-and-tire combinations can increase weight and rolling resistance. Those changes may consume more energy than they save.

Detailed shot of a sleek car wheel featuring a chrome Work Wheels rim, outdoors.FBO Media, Pexels

Advertisement

Switching To Aggressive All-Terrain Tires

Chunkier tires can provide useful off-road traction, but that doesn't guarantee efficiency on pavement. Tire Rack testing found lower fuel economy with certain all-terrain tires compared with highway-oriented alternatives.

Processed with VSCO with se3 presetImpactbumper, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Using Thicker Motor Oil For Extra Protection

Thicker oil might sound better for your engine, but using an unapproved viscosity increases internal resistance. Using 10W-30 instead of specified 5W-30 can lower fuel economy by approximately 1% to 2%.

Woman adding oil to a car engine outdoors in Rasht, Iran, showcasing DIY vehicle care.arvin latifi, Pexels

Advertisement

Keeping Four-Wheel Drive Engaged

More traction sounds helpful, but engaging four-wheel drive on dry pavement doesn't automatically improve efficiency. It increases drivetrain losses and requires additional energy. Use selectable four-wheel drive only under appropriate conditions.

White GMC Yukon XL cruising on a highway in Charlotte, North Carolina, under a clear blue sky.Lee Salem, Pexels

Advertisement

Driving Faster To Finish The Trip Sooner

Getting there faster doesn't mean burning less fuel. Aerodynamic resistance increases with speed, and fuel economy generally declines sharply above 50 mph. A shorter journey measured in minutes can still consume substantially more gasoline.

KahlOrrKahlOrr, Pixabay

Advertisement

Accelerating Hard To Reach Cruising Speed Quickly

Some drivers believe reaching cruising speed as quickly as possible saves fuel. Aggressive acceleration actually demands additional engine power. Smooth, moderate acceleration is generally more economical than repeatedly flooring the accelerator.

Side view of a fast silver sports car in motion on an urban road.Abdullah Dawud, Pexels

Advertisement

Braking At The Last Possible Moment

Maintaining speed until the last second might seem efficient, but hard braking wastes energy you've already spent accelerating. Anticipating traffic and slowing gradually reduces unnecessary acceleration-and-braking cycles.

Feet in sandals on car pedalsWorawat, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Using Cruise Control On Every Hill

Cruise control generally helps on level highways, but hills complicate things. The system may accelerate aggressively or downshift to maintain its setting uphill, potentially using more gasoline than a careful driver would.

Adaptive cruise control operation buttonsProject Kei, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Coasting Downhill In Neutral

This old trick can backfire in modern fuel-injected cars. Many engines temporarily stop injecting fuel during in-gear deceleration. Shifting into neutral instead requires gasoline to keep the engine idling.

A silver SUV navigates a winding rural road surrounded by lush green countryside.jacky xing, Pexels

Advertisement

Staying In Lower Gears For Better Control

Lower gears can provide useful control, but unnecessarily maintaining high engine revolutions consumes more fuel. On suitable roads, shifting into a higher gear at an appropriate speed generally improves efficiency.

Hand of a Person Operating the Gearshift While DrivingGustavo Fring, Pexels

Advertisement

Disabling Automatic Stop-Start Technology

Frequent engine restarts might seem wasteful, but automatic stop-start systems are designed to reduce unnecessary idling. Disabling the feature keeps gasoline burning during stops when the engine could otherwise be switched off.

Start-stop system 2260936287Anadolu, Getty Images

Advertisement

Warming Up The Engine For Several Minutes

Extended winter warm-ups remain popular, but modern engines generally don't need them. Idling burns fuel without covering any distance. Gentle driving usually brings an engine up to operating temperature faster.

A white sports car parked in a snowy suburban driveway during winter snowfall.Erik Mclean, Pexels

Advertisement

Leaving The Engine Running To Avoid Restarting

Restarting a modern engine generally requires less fuel than prolonged idling. Keeping the car running during lengthy parked stops can waste gasoline, even if switching everything off seems inconvenient.

blue bmw m 3 coupe in a parking lotCosmin Grosu, Unsplash

Advertisement

Cooling The Cabin Before Driving

Leaving the engine idling while the air conditioning cools the cabin wastes fuel. Most vehicle cooling systems work more effectively once you're driving. Briefly releasing trapped hot air first also helps.

Detailed view of a car air vent system, showcasing interior design and texture.Asm Arif, Pexels

Advertisement

Keeping The Air Conditioning On Maximum

Blasting the air conditioning throughout a journey can increase fuel consumption unnecessarily. Once the cabin becomes comfortable, adjusting the temperature reduces cooling demand. Maximum cooling isn't always necessary.

Crop anonymous person regulating temperature in car using controller on panel while sitting in carErik Mclean, Pexels

Advertisement

Opening Every Window At Highway Speeds

Turning off the air conditioning sounds economical, but open windows increase aerodynamic drag. At highway speeds, this can offset the savings. Results vary by vehicle, speed, and outside temperature.

A blue sports car speeds down an open road, capturing the thrill of driving.Tnarg, Pexels

Advertisement

Opening The Sunroof To Avoid Air Conditioning

A wide-open sunroof introduces another source of aerodynamic drag. Edmunds testing found that opening an SUV's sunroof worsened mileage even with the air conditioning switched off. Fresh air isn't automatically free.

Porsche 911 CarreraAlexandre Prevot from Nancy, France, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Using A Roof Cargo Box For Better Organization

Moving luggage onto the roof clears cabin space, but it also increases aerodynamic resistance. Large rooftop boxes can reduce fuel economy by 10% to 25% at interstate speeds.

Ground level of contemporary style black racing automobile with shiny surface and luggage rack on roof parked on asphalt with marking lines near building facade in town in parking lotGarvin St. Villier, Pexels

Advertisement

Leaving Empty Roof Racks Installed

An empty roof rack might seem harmless because it's carrying nothing. However, exposed crossbars can still disturb airflow. Removing unnecessary roof equipment can help recover fuel economy, especially during highway driving.

Side view of a silver SUV on a sunny day, parked in a scenic countryside under a bright blue sky.Elizabeth Tamara, Pexels

Advertisement

Towing A Small Trailer Instead Of Packing The Car

A trailer might keep the cabin uncluttered, but towing creates additional weight and aerodynamic resistance. That extra load typically increases fuel consumption, even when the trailer itself seems relatively small.

a white suv pulling a trailer with a boat on itSincerely Media, Unsplash

Advertisement

Driving With A Pickup Truck's Tailgate Down

Lowering the tailgate seems like it should let air escape more freely. However, aerodynamic research and highway testing show that doing so can increase drag and worsen fuel economy.

White pickup truck parked in a snowy industrial area, showcasing its open cargo bed.Vitali Adutskevich, Pexels

Advertisement

Carrying Extra Weight For Better Stability

Keeping unnecessary heavy equipment in your trunk can feel reassuring, but added weight increases fuel consumption. An extra 100 pounds can reduce mileage by approximately 1%, depending on vehicle size.

A man packs an SUV with luggage on a dirt road, preparing for an outdoor adventure.Matheus Bertelli, Pexels

Advertisement

Making Several Short Trips Instead Of Combining Errands

Short drives might seem economical individually, but repeated cold starts waste fuel. Combining errands allows the engine to stay warm. Several cold-start trips can consume considerably more gasoline than one combined journey.

A woman driving a Hyundai car, focusing on the steering wheel and dashboard controls.juan mendez, Pexels

Advertisement

You May Also Like:

How Much Electric Car Range Do You Need?

10 Mistakes To Avoid When Shopping For A New Vehicle

Here’s Why You Should Skip The Automated Car Wash

Sources:  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19


READ MORE

Electric car charging

How Much Electric Car Range Do You Need?

If you're on the fence about getting an electric car and want to make sure it can go the distance, check out these quick tips.
November 10, 2026 Kaddy Gibson
Couple examining new auto with car dealer

Three Things You Shouldn’t Do At The Dealership

Buying a new vehicle is fun, but it can also be complicated. Luckily, with a little preparation, you can leave the lot with a great car for a great price.
November 4, 2026 Kaddy Gibson
carwash_internal

Here’s Why You Should Skip The Automated Car Wash

Keep reading to learn more about the dangers of automatic car washes and how to properly clean your vehicle with a few simple tools.
November 6, 2026 Kaddy Gibson
changetire_internal

Quick Guide To Changing A Flat Tire

Getting a flat tire is never a fun experience. To help you quickly get back on the road, here are five easy steps to safely change a flat tire.
November 5, 2026 Kaddy Gibson
internal

Keep Your Car In Mint Condition With These Simple Tips And Tricks

If you’re a car owner, keeping things in tip-top shape not only helps your vehicle last longer, but also contributes to your safety on the road.
October 31, 2026 Kaddy Gibson
Nissan Altima

Five Cars With The Highest Premiums

Turns out that the type of vehicle you are driving can have more of an impact on your car insurance premium than any hiccups in your driving history.
November 11, 2026 Kaddy Gibson


✕