The Payment Wasn't The Problem
You carefully calculated the monthly payment before financing your car and decided you could afford it. Then you discovered what insuring it would cost. Suddenly, the supposedly manageable purchase is straining your budget. Could getting insurance quotes before choosing the vehicle have prevented this expensive surprise?
Insurance Is Part Of Affordability
Yes. Buyers should generally treat insurance as part of a vehicle's monthly cost rather than something to investigate after agreeing to buy. A $450 loan payment doesn't really cost $450 each month if keeping the car properly insured adds another $250 to your budget.
Premiums Have Been Rising
The problem has become harder to ignore as auto insurance premiums have increased. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) says insurers establish premiums around expected future claims, with costs influenced by personal risk factors and conditions where a vehicle is driven and garaged.
Your Car Changes Everything
Two similarly priced vehicles can produce surprisingly different insurance quotes. Insurers consider the vehicle's make and model alongside numerous driver characteristics. Models associated with expensive repairs, poor safety results, costly replacement values, or greater claims frequency can be more expensive for an insurer to cover.
Financing Complicates The Equation
Financing can make insurance especially important because you may not have complete freedom to choose minimal coverage. Lenders commonly require borrowers to protect financed vehicles with collision and comprehensive coverage in addition to legally required insurance, protecting the lender's financial interest if the vehicle is damaged or destroyed.
Full Coverage Costs More
"Full coverage" isn't actually a single standardized insurance product. The phrase commonly describes a combination of liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Whatever terminology your lender uses, carrying physical-damage protection on the financed vehicle can leave you paying substantially more than you would for liability coverage alone.
Younger Drivers Get Hit
This calculation can be particularly painful for younger buyers. Insurers generally regard younger, inexperienced motorists as higher risks. Current Forbes Advisor data estimates average full-coverage insurance at $398 monthly for a 20-year-old driver, falling to $237 monthly by age 25. Individual premiums can differ dramatically.
Imagine This Scenario
Suppose a 20-year-old finds a desirable used car with a $375 monthly loan payment. An insurance quote approaching the current $398 monthly average for that age would make the combined obligation roughly $773 before gasoline, maintenance, registration, parking, repairs, or other ownership expenses even enter the calculation.
Age Is One Factor
Age isn't the only thing affecting your premium. Insurers can consider your driving record, claims history, location, driving experience, vehicle use, annual mileage, chosen coverage, deductibles, and other permitted factors. This is why somebody else's insurance bill tells you surprisingly little about what yours will be.
Location Matters Too
Where you live can substantially change the calculation. Insurers examine claims experience associated with geographic areas, meaning the same driver and vehicle can cost different amounts to insure in different locations. Urban areas, for example, generally generate more claims than rural areas, according to the NAIC.
Credit May Matter
In many states, insurers are permitted to consider credit-based insurance scores when determining premiums. These aren't the same thing as conventional credit scores used by lenders. State rules vary, however, and some jurisdictions prohibit or restrict the use of credit information in insurance pricing.
Get Quotes First
The simplest defense is remarkably easy: price insurance while you're still shopping for the car. Once you've narrowed your choices to several models, request comparable insurance quotes for each one. You might discover that the vehicle with the slightly higher purchase price actually costs less overall.
Compare Identical Coverage
When comparing quotes, keep the coverage consistent. A $170 monthly quote with high deductibles and lower liability limits isn't necessarily cheaper in a meaningful sense than a $210 quote offering substantially stronger protection. The NAIC recommends providing the same information when requesting quotations from different companies.
Compare Several Insurers
Don't assume one expensive quote means the vehicle is universally expensive to insure. Insurance companies use their own rating systems and can evaluate risks differently. Getting quotes from multiple insurers before purchasing gives you a much better idea of the realistic range you could pay.
Compare Several Cars
Take the process one step further by quoting multiple vehicles. Perhaps you're deciding among three compact SUVs priced around $30,000. Insurance could meaningfully alter their relative affordability. The model with the biggest dealer discount isn't necessarily the one that leaves the most money in your bank account.
Consider The Deductible
A higher collision or comprehensive deductible can reduce premiums, but don't choose one solely to make the monthly number attractive. If you select a $2,000 deductible, consider whether you could actually produce $2,000 unexpectedly after an accident or covered loss without creating another financial problem.
Look For Discounts
Ask about legitimate discounts before concluding the premium is unavoidable. Depending on the insurer and state, possibilities can include multi-vehicle coverage, bundling, good-student discounts, driver education, anti-theft equipment, low mileage, and good-driver discounts. Eligibility and savings vary considerably among companies.
Don't Let Coverage Lapse
Simply dropping required coverage isn't a solution for a financed vehicle. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) warns that if insurance lapses, a lender may obtain force-placed insurance protecting its interest in the vehicle. That coverage can be charged to you while providing far less protection for your own interests.
Understand GAP Separately
GAP (Guaranteed Asset Protection) coverage addresses a different financial risk. If a financed vehicle is totaled or stolen while you owe more than its cash value, GAP may cover some or all of that difference. The CFPB notes that GAP is generally an optional add-on, rather than ordinary auto insurance.
Calculate The Real Payment
Before buying, add the proposed loan payment and actual insurance quote together. Then estimate fuel, routine maintenance, registration, parking, and a reasonable repair allowance. That larger figure is much closer to the monthly financial commitment you're accepting than the payment displayed prominently on a dealer's worksheet.
Leave Yourself Breathing Room
Don't choose a vehicle that consumes every available dollar merely because you can technically make today's payment. Insurance premiums can change at renewal, while repairs and other ownership expenses are unpredictable. A car that's affordable only when absolutely nothing goes wrong isn't comfortably affordable.
Price Insurance Before Buying
The best time to discover that your dream car costs $300 a month to insure is before signing the loan agreement. Get quotes for the specific vehicles you're considering, especially if you're young or financing. Shop the loan and insurance together, because ultimately your budget has to support both.
You May Also Like:
