Trouble in America’s Favorite Truck
The Ford F-150 has been America’s best-selling vehicle for decades, known for toughness and reliability. But now, nearly 1.3 million of them—built between 2015 and 2017—are under the microscope for a very scary problem: sudden, unexpected downshifts at highway speeds. But how did we get here? (because this isn't the first time Ford has had this problem come up in its most popular trucks).
The Legacy of the F-150
The F-150 is more than a truck—it’s a symbol of American grit. For years, it’s topped sales charts and earned customer loyalty. That’s why today’s investigation feels so unsettling. When problems show up in such a trusted vehicle, people naturally start paying closer attention.
OWS Photography, Wikimedia Commons
The Six-Speed Workhorse
At the heart of the issue is Ford’s 6R80 six-speed automatic transmission. It was designed to balance performance, towing strength, and efficiency. Millions of trucks relied on it. But even strong designs can run into trouble if a single component isn’t up to the task.
Alexander Migl, Wikimedia Commons
Why Gear Shifts Matter
When a transmission is working smoothly, drivers will hardly notice it. But when it fails, the effects are immediate and often scary. A sudden downshift can make the truck jolt, slow suddenly, or skid at highway speeds. It’s way more than just a comfort issue—it's a safety one.
Alexander-93, Wikimedia Commons
First Complaints: 2011–2013 Models
The story begins in the early 2010s. Owners of 2011–2013 F-150s started reporting sudden, harsh downshifts while cruising. Imagine driving at 65 mph and the truck unexpectedly drops into first gear. No wonder regulators wanted to take a closer look.
U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Wikimedia Commons
Behind the Wheel Experiences
Drivers shared stories of jolts, shudders, and trucks that felt out of control for a few seconds. Some said it was like “slamming on the brakes without warning.” Even without crashes in every case, the experiences were concerning enough to attract regulators’ attention.
U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Wikimedia Commons
What Engineers Found
The problem came down to the output shaft speed (OSS) sensor. When it misread data, the truck’s computer ordered an unnecessary downshift. It showed how one small sensor could affect the entire system. Ford moved to address it, but more would follow.
INPUT SPEED SENSOR OUTPUT SPEED SENSOR LOCATION REPLACEMENT EXPLAINED, Auto Repair Guys
The First Recall Fix
Ford issued a recall that involved software updates to the powertrain control module (PCM). The fix aimed to stop trucks from reacting so harshly to bad sensor data. For a while, it looked like the issue was under control. But not for long.
Michael Gil from Calgary, AB, Canada, Wikimedia Commons
The 2019 Recall Expansion
By 2019, Ford expanded the recall to cover about 1.48 million F-150s from 2011–2013 after more complaints came in. Again, the remedy was a PCM software update. For many drivers, it seemed like the end of the story. But the trouble didn’t stop there.
Another Blow: 2014 Models
In 2024, nearly 668,000 F-150s from the 2014 model year were recalled for the same issue. Once again, sudden downshifts at high speeds posed risks of rear-wheel lockup. Ford realized this wasn’t an isolated problem. It was showing up in newer trucks, too.
order_242 from Chile, Wikimedia Commons
Complaints Resurface in New Models
By 2015–2017, owners began experiencing the same problem. Trucks unexpectedly slammed into lower gears at highway speeds. For a vehicle so central to Ford’s reputation, this was more than a mechanical issue—it was a question of reliability.
RL GNZLZ from Chile, Wikimedia Commons
The Human Impact
Owners described towing trailers when their trucks suddenly jolted, or commuting when the transmission unexpectedly downshifted. Some reported skidding or struggling to stay in control. Even if crashes weren’t confirmed, the real-world stories made the risks feel clear.
The Scope of the New Problem
NHTSA logged 138 complaints tied to 2015–2017 F-150s with six-speed transmissions. That may not sound like much at first glance, but because nearly 1.27 million trucks could be affected, regulators saw enough evidence to launch a new investigation.
Launch of a Preliminary Evaluation
In March 2025, NHTSA opened a Preliminary Evaluation into the issue. This first stage gathers complaints, engineering data, and input from Ford. It doesn’t guarantee a recall yet—but it signals that the government sees a potential safety concern.
Dave Parker, Wikimedia Commons
Why Downshifts Are So Dangerous
An unexpected downshift can make the truck slow suddenly, lock the rear wheels, or skid. On a crowded highway, even a moment of instability can be risky. That’s why NHTSA treats gear-shift issues as more than just mechanical quirks.
Ford’s Initial Response
Ford has confirmed the complaints but emphasized that no crashes or injuries have been officially tied to them. The company is cooperating with NHTSA as it investigates further. For now, Ford hasn’t issued a recall but is under pressure to act quickly.
What Happens During an Investigation
NHTSA investigations typically start with a Preliminary Evaluation. If risks seem widespread, the case escalates to an Engineering Analysis. That deeper stage often leads to recalls, but only after regulators confirm a defect. Right now, the F-150 case is at step one.
Could Another Recall Be Coming?
If the investigation confirms a defect, Ford may need to recall more than a million trucks. The fix would likely involve a PCM software update, as with past recalls. Until then, owners are left waiting to see whether action will follow.
Why Recalls Keep Expanding
Automakers often start with limited recalls, then expand them as more data comes in. That’s what happened with the 2011–2013 models. For Ford, the repetition raises questions about why the problem keeps resurfacing across different years.
Raymond Wambsgans, Wikimedia Commons
Comparing to Other Big Recalls
Other automakers have faced transmission and safety recalls, too. The difference here is scale. Because the F-150 is America’s best-selling vehicle, even rare issues affect hundreds of thousands of drivers—and draw national attention.
Why This Hurts Ford’s Reputation
Ford promotes the F-150 as “Built Ford Tough.” Safety investigations and repeated recalls can chip away at that image. While most drivers never experience the issue, the headlines alone can shake confidence in such a high-profile truck.
How Regulators See It
From NHTSA’s perspective, the focus is on preventing accidents. A truck that can suddenly downshift without warning is a potential hazard. Even with relatively few complaints, the possibility of a high-speed incident is enough to justify an investigation.
OWS Photography, Wikimedia Commons
Advice for Drivers: Check Your VIN
If you own a 2015–2017 F-150, it’s smart to check your VIN on Ford’s recall site or NHTSA’s lookup tool. This shows whether your truck has any current recalls and keeps you updated as new information develops.
What to Do If You Notice Symptoms
If your truck suddenly jolts, shudders, or drops gears unexpectedly, visit a Ford dealer. Even without a recall, technicians can diagnose problems and document your case. That documentation also helps regulators see the issue’s scope more clearly.
How Dealers Handle Recalls
When recalls are issued, repairs are done at no cost. For these transmission problems, fixes usually involve software updates to the PCM. The process is relatively quick, but it only happens once a recall is officially in place.
Why Software Updates Matter
Modern trucks are computer-driven. A software update can change how the PCM responds to faulty sensor data, preventing harsh downshifts. It’s not about replacing every sensor—it’s about teaching the system to react more safely if one misreads.
What Drivers Fear Most
Beyond the mechanics, owners worry about peace of mind. Drivers buy F-150s expecting reliability. The idea of losing control on the highway—even if rare—leaves some uneasy. They want reassurance that Ford is doing everything possible to prevent it.
Raymond Wambsgans from Akron Ohio, USA, Wikimedia Commons
Possible Outcomes of the Investigation
The investigation could end three ways: NHTSA may close the case, escalate it to Engineering Analysis, or require Ford to recall affected trucks. Which path it takes depends on what regulators uncover in the months ahead.
Conclusion: A Chapter Still Unfolding
The downshift issue in 2015–2017 F-150s is still under review. With regulators digging deeper and Ford cooperating, owners are waiting for answers. Whatever the outcome, one thing is clear: when America’s top-selling truck faces questions, the entire auto industry pays attention.
You Might Also Like:
The Most Reliable Pickup Trucks Ever Made
10 Of The Rarest Pickup Trucks Ever Made
